Subject Line Tester
By Carlos Gil, Founder & Editor, The Best Network · Updated
Your subject line is the only part of the email everyone sees, and it’s usually the part written last, in a hurry, after the real work is done. That’s backwards.
Paste a subject line below for a 0 to 100 checklist score and the specific issues that could get it cut off on mobile, flagged by a filter or ignored. It won’t write a better line for you. It will stop you sending a bad one.
Key takeaways
- The score is a risk checklist, not an open-rate prediction: length, whole-word trigger phrases, emoji, all-caps words and exclamation marks.
- Under 10 characters is flagged Too short, and over 60 characters is likely to be cut off on mobile.
- In the US, CAN-SPAM requires the subject line to accurately reflect the message (FTC, checked Oct 19, 2026).
- Google's sender guidelines say not to start a subject with Re: or Fwd: unless the message is a real reply or forward.
What the tester checks
Length. Inbox apps truncate subject lines at different points depending on the app and the screen, so the tester treats 60 characters as the point where mobile truncation becomes likely and 80 as the point where most of the line disappears. Very short lines lose points too: three words rarely give anyone a reason to open.
Trigger phrases. Words such as free, guarantee, cash and act now are matched as whole words or phrases, longest first, so “carefree” doesn’t count as “free” and “risk-free” is counted once.
Shouting. A word of four or more letters in capitals counts as all caps. Short acronyms such as USA, FAQ and ROI don’t.
Punctuation and emoji. One exclamation mark and one emoji are free. Each extra one costs points, and “!!!” is scored only as exclamation marks, never twice.
Fake replies. A subject that starts with Re: or Fwd: loses points, because Google tells bulk senders not to use them unless the message really is a reply or a forward.
What it can’t tell you
Spam filters at Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft weigh your authentication, your sender reputation and how subscribers have engaged with your past mail far more than any single word. A perfect score from a domain without SPF, DKIM and DMARC can still land in spam, and a line with “free” in it can land in the inbox for a sender people want to hear from.
It also can’t tell you whether a line is interesting. That depends on your audience, and the only honest test is a split test judged on clicks, because Apple Mail Privacy Protection inflates opens.
How this tool works
The score starts at 100 and deducts points: 45 for under 10 characters or 15 for under 20, 20 for over 60 and 20 more for over 80, 8 per trigger phrase, 5 per emoji after the first, 8 per all-caps word, 6 per exclamation mark after the first, and 15 for a Re: or Fwd: prefix. The weights are editorial rules of thumb, not measured results.
Sources
Checked October 19, 2026.
What to do next
Fix anything flagged in red, then stop polishing. If two versions both score Decent or better, send both to a slice of your list and keep the one that earns more clicks.
A subject line can’t rescue an email nobody asked for, but a lazy one can bury an email everybody did.
FAQ
How long should an email subject line be?
Short enough that the point survives truncation, and long enough to say something. Inbox previews cut subject lines at different lengths by app and screen, so this tester flags anything over 60 characters as likely to be cut on mobile and anything under 10 characters as too short to tell a reader why to open. Put the important words first.
Does this tool predict my open rate?
No. The score is a checklist of common risks: length, words that often trip spam filters, emoji count, all-caps words and exclamation marks. Open rates depend on your list, sender name and timing, and Apple Mail Privacy Protection inflates measured opens.
Will one spam-trigger word send my email to spam?
Rarely on its own. Modern filters weigh sender reputation, authentication and engagement far more than single words. Trigger words add risk, so this tool deducts points for each one it finds, matching whole words only.
Do subject lines have legal rules?
In the US, yes. The FTC's CAN-SPAM guide says the subject line must accurately reflect the content of the message. Google's sender guidelines add that subject lines shouldn't start with Re: or Fwd: unless the message is a real reply or forward.