Kit vs Substack
On a $10 subscription, Substack keeps $1 and Kit keeps 65 cents. Multiply that by every paying reader, every month you publish.
Scores are each product’s editorial review score
How do Kit and Substack compare side by side?
Free plan
Up to 10,000 subscribers, unlimited broadcastsFree to publish at any list sizeCut of paid subscriptions
3.5% + 30¢ per sale, every plan10% of each paymentCard processing
ExtraExtraPaid plan
Creator $39/mo at 1,000 subscribers ($33 billed yearly)NoneDigital products
Products, subscriptions and tips on every planPaid subscriptions onlyAutomations
Visual automations and sequences on Creator and ProWelcome email; no workflow builderDiscovery
Creator Network recommendations; paid recommendations on Creator and ProNotes, the Substack app and recommendationsList export
CSV exportCSV exportShopify
Tags subscribers by purchaseNo integration
| Category | KitRead review → | Substack |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Up to 10,000 subscribers, unlimited broadcasts | Free to publish at any list size |
| Cut of paid subscriptions | 3.5% + 30¢ per sale, every plan | 10% of each payment |
| Card processing | Extra | Extra |
| Paid plan | Creator $39/mo at 1,000 subscribers ($33 billed yearly) | None |
| Digital products | Products, subscriptions and tips on every plan | Paid subscriptions only |
| Automations | Visual automations and sequences on Creator and Pro | Welcome email; no workflow builder |
| Discovery | Creator Network recommendations; paid recommendations on Creator and Pro | Notes, the Substack app and recommendations |
| List export | CSV export | CSV export |
| Shopify | Tags subscribers by purchase | No integration |
| Get started | Try Kit free | Visit Substack |
Key takeaways
On a $10 monthly subscription, Substack keeps $1 and Kit keeps about 65 cents. That gap runs on every paying reader for as long as you publish. If you’re building a business you plan to own for years, I’d pick Kit. If you need readers before you need margin, start on Substack.
- Kit’s free plan sells paid subscriptions and digital products for up to 10,000 subscribers, at 3.5% + 30¢ per sale (as of October 2026).
- For any subscription priced above about $4.62, Kit’s fee is smaller than Substack’s 10%. Below that, Substack takes less.
- Kit Creator, which adds automations and sequences, is $39 a month at 1,000 subscribers, $139 at 10,000, $379 at 50,000 and $679 at 100,000.
- Substack costs nothing until readers pay, and its Notes feed and app put you in front of readers already on Substack.
- Both let you export your subscriber list as a CSV.
What each one costs as you grow
Monthly list prices as of October 2026: Kit checked October 19 on its pricing page, Substack checked October 19 on its going-paid page. Card processing fees are extra on both.
| Subscribers | Kit | Substack |
|---|---|---|
| 1,000 | $0 on Free, or $39 on Creator | $0; 10% of paid revenue |
| 10,000 | $0 on Free, or $139 on Creator | $0; 10% of paid revenue |
| 50,000 | $379 on Creator | $0; 10% of paid revenue |
| 100,000 | $679 on Creator | $0; 10% of paid revenue |
Kit adds 3.5% + 30¢ to every sale on top of its plan price. Run the math on a $10 subscription: Kit Creator saves about 35 cents per payment over Substack, so at 1,000 subscribers the $39 plan pays for itself once roughly 112 readers pay. Above 10,000 subscribers Kit needs a paid plan, and a free newsletter that never charges costs nothing on Substack at any size.
Full plan and fee breakdown: Kit review.
Ownership and the reader relationship
Both platforms let you export your subscribers. The difference is where the relationship lives day to day. On Kit, readers know you through your own landing pages, sequences and storefront. On Substack, much of the experience runs through Substack’s app, feed and recommendations, which is how it helps you grow and also why more of your brand sits on its surface.
If you sell more than subscriptions, Kit carries the rest: ebooks, courses, templates and tips from the same account, with sequences that deliver them.
Discovery
Substack wins this one. Notes and the Substack app reach readers who already subscribe to other publications there, which can bring a new writer subscribers without paid promotion. Kit’s Creator Network lets newsletters recommend each other, and paid recommendations run on Creator and Pro, but there’s no feed-style surface like Notes.
Switching from Substack to Kit
- Export your subscribers from Substack as a CSV and import them into Kit.
- Migration help: on Creator and Pro, Kit’s free migration service moves subscribers, tags, lists and segments.
- Rebuild welcome emails and any paid tiers in Kit before you announce the move.
What do 500 readers paying $8 a month leave you on each?
Take a newsletter with 5,000 subscribers, 500 of them paying $8 a month. That’s $4,000 in gross revenue. Card fees come on top on both platforms; at Stripe’s standard US rate of 2.9% + 30¢, that comes to about $266 a month on 500 charges (Stripe pricing, as of October 2026).
- Substack: 10% is $400, so you keep about $3,334.
- Kit Free: 3.5% + 30¢ is 58¢ a payment, or $290, so you keep about $3,444.
- Kit Creator: the same $290 plus the $89 plan at 5,000 subscribers leaves about $3,355.
At $8, Kit Creator barely beats Substack, because the 22-cent fee gap on each payment only just covers the plan. Raise the price and the gap widens. At $15 a month, Substack takes $1.50 a payment and Kit about 83 cents, so 500 readers at that price leave you roughly $248 more a month on Kit Creator, after the plan. Below about $4.62 a month, Substack’s cut is the smaller one, and a Kit plan fee only widens that gap.
What happens to paying subscribers when you move them to Kit?
This is the part most switching guides skip. Kit’s own Substack migration article (dated September 12, 2026) says free subscribers come across in a CSV import, and paid subscribers’ contact records can be imported with a “Paid subscribers” tag. Their subscriptions and payment details don’t move. Kit’s suggested workaround is to cancel their Substack subscriptions and ask them to subscribe again in Kit, after telling them in advance.
That means every paying reader has to decide to pay you twice. Plan the move like a relaunch: set up payments and a Subscription product in Kit first, announce the date more than once, and expect some readers not to follow. Past posts also don’t import automatically; Kit has you recreate them as broadcasts published to the web with their original dates.
One billing detail works in your favor. Kit bills only confirmed subscribers, so unsubscribed, bounced and complained addresses in a messy Substack export don’t raise your bill. Cold subscribers still count: Kit marks someone cold after 90 days without an open or click (30 days for newer subscribers).
Limitations: where each one falls short
Kit
- Discovery: Creator Network recommendations; paid recommendations on Creator and Pro (Substack: Notes, the Substack app and recommendations)
Substack
- Cut of paid subscriptions: 10% of each payment (Kit: 3.5% + 30¢ per sale, every plan)
- Digital products: Paid subscriptions only (Kit: Products, subscriptions and tips on every plan)
- Automations: Welcome email; no workflow builder (Kit: Visual automations and sequences on Creator and Pro)
- Shopify: No integration (Kit: Tags subscribers by purchase)
Which should you choose, Kit or Substack?
Pick Kit if you sell products alongside your newsletter, charge more than about $5 a month, or want sequences and a storefront you control. Pick Substack if you’re starting with no audience, want paid subscriptions live today with almost no setup, and need its network to find your first readers. Looking wider? See the Substack alternatives and beehiiv vs Substack.
Discovery gets you your first thousand readers. Ownership is what you have left when a platform changes its rules.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
- Kit pricing (checked Oct 19, 2026)
- Substack: going paid (checked Oct 19, 2026)
- EmailToolTester: email deliverability test, January 2024 round (checked Oct 19, 2026)
- Substack: going paid (checked Oct 19, 2026)
- Stripe pricing: US domestic card fee (checked Oct 19, 2026)
- Kit help: migrating from Substack to Kit (dated Sep 12, 2026) (checked Oct 19, 2026)
- Kit help: subscriber profile page and status (billing by status) (checked Oct 19, 2026)
